The Rules Are Changing, and Not Always in the Same Direction
For employers conducting criminal background investigations, October 2026 has been a particularly eventful month.
A California appellate court has reaffirmed employers' discretion to make hiring decisions involving criminal records. New York City has adopted detailed regulations identifying hiring practices that independently violate its Fair Chance Act. Meanwhile, San Francisco has expanded restrictions on certain out-of-state criminal records, tightened adverse action procedures and increased penalties.
These developments reflect a larger challenge confronting employers nationwide: Fair Chance compliance is becoming an increasingly complicated patchwork of state and local laws, regulations, court decisions and enforcement priorities.
The rules can differ substantially depending on where an applicant will work, where an employer operates and even where the underlying criminal conduct occurred. For organizations hiring across multiple jurisdictions, a background screening policy that satisfies one state's requirements may create legal exposure in another.
California: A Court Reaffirms Employer Discretion
In a significant decision published October 13, the California Court of Appeal addressed an important question under the state's Fair Chance Act: Can courts second-guess an employer's conclusion that an applicant's criminal history disqualifies them from a position?
In McInerney v. Regents of the University of California, UCLA conditionally offered an applicant an office assistant position. A subsequent background investigation revealed several drug-related convictions dating back approximately 14 years.
UCLA notified the applicant that the convictions could disqualify him and offered an opportunity to submit rehabilitation or mitigating information. Instead, the applicant sent hostile communications to university personnel. UCLA withdrew the offer before the required five-business-day response period expired.
The applicant sued, alleging that UCLA violated the Fair Chance Act. Although UCLA had failed to provide the full response period, the jury determined that the violation had not caused the applicant to lose the position. The appellate court affirmed the judgment.
More significantly, the court concluded that California's Fair Chance Act does not authorize courts or juries to substitute their judgment for an employer's individualized assessment of criminal history. The statute requires employers to follow prescribed procedures before making an adverse hiring decision. It does not necessarily dictate the outcome of that decision.
The court also held that a procedural violation, standing alone, did not entitle the applicant to damages without proof that the violation caused harm. This provides meaningful guidance for California employers, particularly as the California Civil Rights Department has pursued an expansive interpretation of the statute and increased enforcement activity.
However, the decision should not be mistaken for permission to disregard procedural requirements. Employers must still conduct individualized assessments, provide required notices and afford applicants the prescribed opportunity to respond. The court protected employer discretion, not shortcuts in the screening process.
San Francisco: When an Out-of-State Conviction Cannot Be Used In-State
While California's appellate court was clarifying employer discretion under statewide law, San Francisco was moving in a different direction.
Amendments to the city's Fair Chance Ordinance prohibit covered employers from considering certain out-of-state arrests and convictions when the underlying conduct would have been lawful in California. The restrictions address records involving reproductive healthcare, gender-affirming care, drag performances and pregnancy loss.
Consider the practical implications. An applicant applies for a position in San Francisco. A background investigation identifies a criminal conviction from another state. The record is accurate, the conviction is valid and the conduct was unlawful where it occurred. Yet if the conviction falls within one of San Francisco's newly protected categories and involves conduct lawful in California, the employer may be prohibited from considering it.
The employer is therefore confronted with two distinct questions: Is the criminal record accurate and legally reportable? And may the employer lawfully use that information when making its hiring decision? Those questions do not always have the same answer.
San Francisco's amendments also establish additional adverse action requirements, including acknowledgment of certain applicant responses, deadlines for final notices and mandatory withdrawal of proposed adverse actions in specified circumstances.
Penalties have increased as well, with administrative fines reaching $1,000 for a first violation, $2,000 for a second and $4,000 for subsequent violations.
These changes illustrate an important emerging issue: the legal significance of a criminal record may depend not only on the jurisdiction where the offense occurred, but also on the jurisdiction where the employment decision is made.
New York City: A Different Regulatory Approach
As we reported earlier this month in our white paper examining New York City's Fair Chance Act, the New York City Commission on Human Rights has adopted amended regulations effective October 30, 2026.
The regulations implement and clarify statutory changes dating to 2021 while providing additional detail concerning criminal background inquiries, individualized assessments, applicant response periods and adverse employment decisions.
New York City's framework generally requires a two-stage hiring process, with noncriminal background information evaluated before a conditional offer and criminal history considered afterward.
The amended regulations expressly identify certain practices as violations, including prohibited pre-offer criminal-history inquiries, failure to provide required Fair Chance materials, insufficient response periods and failure to conduct a new assessment when material errors in criminal-history information are identified.
Employers must provide applicants with at least five business days to respond to a proposed adverse decision. That period begins after the required materials have been received and may need to be extended depending on the circumstances. The regulations also make clear that an inconsistency between an applicant's account and a background report does not automatically establish intentional misrepresentation.
The rules extend protections to certain current employees and narrowly interpret exemptions involving legally mandated background checks.
The contrast with California is instructive. While the California appellate court emphasized limits on judicial review of an employer's individualized assessment under the statewide statute, New York City's regulations place substantial emphasis on compliance with prescribed procedures and substantive restrictions governing the use of criminal history.
The two jurisdictions are not necessarily in direct legal conflict. They regulate different employers under different statutes. But they demonstrate how dramatically the obligations governing similar hiring decisions can vary.
One Background Investigation, Multiple Legal Frameworks
Imagine a national employer recruiting for positions in California, New York City and several other states. The employer uses the same background screening provider, receives similarly formatted criminal history reports and maintains a companywide policy requiring individualized review before withdrawing a conditional offer.
That consistency may be operationally convenient, but it does not guarantee legal compliance. In one jurisdiction, the employer may have discretion to reach a hiring decision after completing the prescribed assessment. In another, certain criminal records may be prohibited from consideration altogether. Elsewhere, the employer may face different notice requirements, waiting periods, documentation standards or restrictions on when criminal information can be obtained.
Even within California, statewide requirements may differ from those imposed by San Francisco, Los Angeles or other local jurisdictions. Fair Chance obligations operate alongside the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and applicable state consumer reporting laws. Those laws govern important aspects of obtaining, reporting and using background information, but they do not necessarily resolve whether a particular criminal record may lawfully influence an employment decision.
Although employers and consumer reporting agencies have distinct legal obligations, effective compliance is best approached as a shared responsibility. Employers should not have to navigate this increasingly complex environment without the benefit of their screening provider's expertise. A knowledgeable background investigation partner can help identify emerging regulatory developments, explain their practical implications and work collaboratively with employers to align screening procedures with applicable requirements.
At Thuro, we view compliance as a shared responsibility and an ongoing partnership with our clients. Our attorney-led compliance team works alongside employers to help them understand the changing legal landscape and its implications for their screening programs. Through regular legal alerts, educational webinars and direct compliance support, we help clients stay informed about emerging requirements and evaluate how those developments may affect their hiring practices. Our objective is not simply to deliver accurate background investigations, but to provide the information, education and support employers need to make informed, defensible hiring decisions.
Compliance Requires More Than a Nationwide Policy
The accelerating pace of these developments calls for a more deliberate approach to background screening compliance. Employers should evaluate their programs across several dimensions:
- Jurisdiction: Identify applicable state and local requirements based on the position, employer operations and relevant employment circumstances.
- Timing: Confirm when criminal-history inquiries and investigations may lawfully occur.
- Permissible information: Distinguish records that may be utilized from records employers are prohibited from considering.
- Individualized assessment: Apply the correct statutory factors and maintain documentation supporting the process.
- Adverse action: Ensure notices, response periods, reassessments and final decisions satisfy applicable federal, state and local requirements.
- Ongoing monitoring: Review new legislation, regulatory changes, enforcement activity and judicial decisions before outdated procedures become systemic compliance problems.
For employers operating in multiple jurisdictions, these requirements increasingly demand coordination among human resources, legal counsel, hiring managers and background screening providers.
The Bigger Picture
Fair Chance laws are not moving along a single, predictable path. Courts are defining the limits of existing statutes. Regulators are clarifying and expanding procedural obligations. Legislatures and local governments are restricting the use of additional categories of criminal history. Enforcement agencies and private litigants continue to test the boundaries of employer discretion.
These developments are occurring simultaneously, sometimes producing materially different obligations for employers operating just miles apart.
The lesson is not that employers must abandon criminal background screening. Properly conducted investigations remain an important component of responsible hiring, workforce protection and risk management. Rather, employers must recognize that the rules governing criminal background screening are increasingly local, increasingly detailed and continually evolving.
Navigating this environment requires more than an accurate background investigation or a written compliance policy. It requires continuing education, informed decision-making and collaboration among employers, their legal advisers and their background screening partners.
At Thuro, we believe that by combining investigative expertise with attorney-led compliance support, ongoing legal updates and educational resources, we work in partnership with our clients to help them respond confidently to changing requirements.
An accurate background investigation remains essential. Equally important is having a knowledgeable partner to help navigate the rules governing how its findings may be used.
About the Author
Kevin P. Prendergast, JD is the President of Thuro and a nationally recognized authority on employment background investigations and compliance. With more than 30 years of experience in the industry, he has worked with leading professional services firms, law firms, financial institutions and global organizations to design compliant and effective background investigation programs.

















.png)

