The NYC Fair Chance Act: What the October 2026 Regulations Mean for Employers

Executive Summary
Earlier this month, the New York City Commission on Human Rights adopted final regulations implementing and clarifying the City's Fair Chance Act (FCA). Effective October 30, 2026, the rules largely codify obligations already established by the 2021 statutory amendments and Commission guidance. Their significance is not that employers face an entirely new screening law. Rather, the regulations make particular procedural failures explicit, sharpen standards for individualized decision-making and eliminate a former early-resolution enforcement procedure.
For employers, the message is straightforward: an accurate background report and a defensible employment concern do not, standing alone, establish compliance. The timing of the investigation, access to criminal-history information, consideration of the applicant's circumstances and documentation of the decision all matter.
The Two-Stage Process Remains the Foundation
The FCA generally requires employers to evaluate an applicant's noncriminal qualifications before extending a conditional offer of employment. Only after that offer may the employer inquire into or consider criminal history, subject to applicable exceptions. The October regulations codify this two-tier approach rather than relaxing it. A conditional offer is not a device for postponing routine, readily available noncriminal screening.
There is an important operational distinction. The Commission's earlier enforcement guidance recognizes a limited alternative where obtaining separate reports presents a substantial impediment: an employer may use an effective system that segregates criminal information and prevents hiring decision-makers from accessing it before the conditional offer. The employer must be able to demonstrate that the information was inaccessible. Accordingly, employers should not confuse a required two-stage decision process with an absolute requirement for two physically separate reports in every circumstance.
An employer should also review whether applications, internet searches, recruiter communications and third-party screening instructions reveal criminal history prematurely.
Merely instructing applicants to skip criminal-history questions does not necessarily cure an unlawful pre-offer inquiry.
Process Failures Can Be Violations in Their Own Right
The adopted rules expressly identify certain per se violations. For example, requesting criminal-history information on an employment application before a conditional offer may violate the FCA even if the form includes a disclaimer. The regulations also address failures to perform a new Fair Chance analysis when material deficiencies are identified before an adverse decision.
The Commission has also removed its former early-resolution procedure for Commission-initiated Fair Chance complaints. This does not establish that every violation will result in a greater penalty, but it removes a previously available regulatory resolution mechanism. Employers should treat the design and operation of their screening workflow as a substantive compliance issue, not an administrative afterthought.
Individualized Assessment Means More Than a Screening Matrix
When criminal history may lawfully be considered, an employer contemplating adverse action must undertake the required individualized Fair Chance Employment Analysis. The regulations clarify the standards for determining whether conduct bears a direct relationship to specific job duties or presents an unreasonable risk. The existence of a conviction, or the seriousness of an offense standing alone, generally does not establish unreasonable risk. Applicable statutory factors and evidence of mitigation must be considered.
Automated rules and job-specific adjudication matrices can improve consistency and help organize the relevant facts. They do not replace the employer's obligation to exercise judgment, consider mitigating circumstances and document the individualized analysis. Final employment decisions remain with the employer.
Candidate Responses and Corrected Information Matter
The rules expressly establish a minimum five-business-day response period for applicants as well as employees following receipt of the Fair Chance Act Notice. Employers must consider relevant information submitted in response and reassess the proposed decision where appropriate. A material error in the underlying criminal history, including an incorrect case disposition, may require a new analysis before adverse action.
This creates a critical connection between accurate background reporting and sound employment decision-making. A consumer reporting agency may have duties under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act to investigate disputed report information; separately, the employer must satisfy its own FCA obligations when evaluating corrected or supplemental information. A completed reinvestigation should not be mistaken for completion of the employer's individualized Fair Chance process.
The rules also clarify that a discrepancy between self-reported history and a criminal background report does not, by itself, establish intentional misrepresentation. Employers considering action on that ground must provide supporting information, allow the required response period and consider the individual's explanation.
The Rules Extend Beyond Initial Hiring
The FCA also affects certain employment decisions involving existing employees. The amended regulations establish a rebuttable presumption that unpaid leave exceeding five business days during a Fair Chance review is unreasonable and may amount to adverse action. Employers should therefore review post-hire screening, suspension and investigation protocols as carefully as applicant-screening procedures.
What Employers Should Do Now
Employers should review application language and pre-offer searches; confirm that conditional offers occur at the appropriate stage; verify that criminal-history access is technically restricted when segregation is used; review Fair Chance notices, delivery records and response periods; and confirm that adverse action decisions can be reopened when relevant information is corrected or supplemented. HR, legal, recruiting and screening providers should understand where their responsibilities begin and end.
How Thuro Supports a Defensible Screening Process
Thuro helps employers obtain accurate, source-based investigative information and structure background screening programs around applicable legal requirements. Our investigative model, reporting capabilities, client support and technology-enabled workflows can help employers coordinate screening stages, evaluate documented findings and respond to disputes. These capabilities support compliance, but do not displace the employer's responsibility to apply the Fair Chance factors, evaluate candidate responses and make the final employment decision.
The October regulations reinforce a broader lesson: the quality of a background screening program is measured not only by what it uncovers, but by whether the information is obtained, delivered and used through a disciplined, legally defensible process.
About the Author
Kevin Prendergast is the President of Thuro and a nationally recognized authority on employment background investigations and compliance. With more than 30 years of experience in the industry, he has worked with leading professional services firms, law firms, financial institutions and global organizations to design compliant and effective background investigation programs.
A licensed attorney since 1987, Kevin focuses on the legal and regulatory frameworks governing employment screening, including the Fair Credit Reporting Act, emerging identity fraud risks and the responsible use of investigative technologies. He regularly advises employers on building programs that protect their workforce, clients and systems while maintaining compliance with evolving laws and regulations.
This white paper is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employers should consult legal counsel regarding specific compliance obligations.
















.png)

