AI Is Making Employment Decisions. Are Humans Still in Charge?

Artificial intelligence is no longer a future issue for human resources. Employers are using technology to screen applications, rank candidates, recommend selections and assist with other employment decisions. In many organizations, AI may already be embedded in recruiting platforms and HR systems without senior leaders thinking of it as a separate AI tool.
November 19, 2026
Kevin Prendergast
President

As AI moves deeper into hiring decisions, lawmakers and courts are increasingly demanding transparency, accountability and meaningful human judgment.

Artificial intelligence is no longer a future issue for human resources. Employers are using technology to screen applications, rank candidates, recommend selections and assist with other employment decisions. In many organizations, AI may already be embedded in recruiting platforms and HR systems without senior leaders thinking of it as a separate AI tool.

The legal question is therefore shifting. It is no longer simply whether employers may use AI. Increasingly, the question is how employers use it, what they understand about it and whether a human remains meaningfully responsible for the decision.

The Algorithm Does Not Assume the Employer's Responsibility

Pending class-action litigation against Workday illustrates the stakes. In Mobley v. Workday, applicants allege that Workday's AI-powered hiring tools caused unlawful disparate impacts based on protected characteristics. Workday denies wrongdoing, and the case remains pending. The plaintiffs moved for class certification in September 2026, with a hearing scheduled for March 2027.

The significance extends beyond one vendor. Employers increasingly rely on third-party technology to sort, score and recommend candidates. Delegating part of the hiring process to sophisticated software does not eliminate the need to understand how the process operates or the legal risks created by its results.

For HR and legal leaders, the practical question is straightforward: if a system influences who advances and who does not, who inside the organization understands why?

States Are Drawing the Guardrails

Illinois now expressly regulates AI in employment decisions. Effective January 1, 2026, the Illinois Human Rights Act prohibits employers from using AI in recruitment, hiring, promotion, training, discipline, discharge and other employment decisions when its use has a discriminatory effect. The law also prohibits using ZIP codes as a proxy for protected classes and requires notice when AI is used for covered employment purposes.

Colorado has taken a different approach. Its Automated Decision-Making Technology Act, effective January 1, 2027, applies when automated technology materially influences consequential decisions, including employment. Among other protections, it gives affected individuals the right to request meaningful human review and reconsideration following certain adverse outcomes.

California has now added another marker. The No Robo Bosses Act, signed September 30, 2026 and operative July 1, 2027, prohibits employers from relying solely on automated decision systems to discipline or terminate workers. When an employer primarily relies on such a system, the law requires human oversight and verification.

These laws differ in scope and mechanics. Their direction, however, is increasingly recognizable: employers may use sophisticated technology, but responsibility for consequential employment decisions does not simply transfer to the technology.

Human Involvement Is Not the Same as Human Judgment

A human being somewhere in the workflow is not necessarily meaningful oversight. A manager who simply accepts a score, ranking or recommendation may add little protection if that person does not understand what the system considered or has no realistic ability to question the result.

The emerging regulatory direction points toward something more substantive: understand the system's intended use and limitations, know what information materially influences its output, independently consider relevant evidence and give the human reviewer genuine authority to disagree with the technology.

Start With a Map

For many employers, the first compliance question may be surprisingly basic: Do you know everywhere AI is influencing employment decisions?

An effective inventory should identify the tools being used, the decisions they support, the data they consider, the vendor responsible for the technology and the point at which human review occurs. Employers should also understand whether new AI functionality can appear through routine platform updates or optional modules.

From there, HR, legal and compliance leaders can evaluate notice requirements, discrimination risks, vendor responsibilities, documentation and the adequacy of human review. The goal is not to eliminate useful technology. It is to ensure that efficiency does not outrun accountability.

What Employers Should Take Away

AI can help employers process information at a scale and speed that human teams cannot match. But employment decisions affect people, create legal exposure and often require context that cannot be reduced to a score.

The emerging lesson from legislation and litigation is increasingly clear: employers should know where AI is operating, understand what role it plays and preserve meaningful human responsibility for consequential decisions.

AI can assist the decision. It should not become an excuse for why no one understood it.

How Thuro Fits Into a Human-Centered Process

Background screening is one part of the broader employment decision process. Thuro combines technology with investigator-led analysis to provide employers with accurate, contextual information while preserving human review. Our one case, one analyst model and dedicated client teams are designed to help employers understand what findings mean rather than simply receive an automated result.

As employment technology evolves, Thuro works with clients and their legal counsel to support legally grounded screening programs that integrate compliance, technology and human judgment.

About the Author

Kevin Prendergast | President, Thuro

Kevin Prendergast has more than 30 years of experience in the background screening and investigative due diligence industry. He oversees the compliance program at Thuro and works closely with clients and their legal counsel to design and maintain legally compliant corporate investigation and background screening programs.

Kevin is a graduate of the Cleveland-Marshall College of Law and has been licensed to practice law since 1987. He is an active member of the Professional Background Screeners Association and holds advanced Fair Credit Reporting Act certification. Under his leadership, Thuro continues a long tradition of providing investigator-led, legally grounded background investigations for employers in highly regulated and security-sensitive sectors. Kevin can be reached at kprendergast@thuro.ai.

‍

Related Post